top of page

Discover New Jersey


The Ultimate Guide to the Best Pizza Places in New Jersey: 30 Must-Try Pizzerias

New Jerseyans are passionate about many things, but if there's one topic that unites them, it's their undying love for pizza. With a plethora of options spanning various styles and flavors, finding the best pizza places in New Jersey can be a delicious challenge. To help narrow down your choices, we've curated a list of 30 must-visit pizzerias across the Garden State. From classic joints steeped in tradition to innovative eateries pushing the boundaries of pizza perfection, these establishments promise a slice of culinary heaven.

Nestled in Morristown, Coniglio’s Old Fashioned may be the new kid on the block, but it's already making waves in the pizza scene. Owner Nino Coniglio's dedication to perfecting the dough results in pizzas that rival those of established favorites.

2. Dominick’s Pizza (Totowa)

Dominick's Pizza in Totowa is a haven for square pie enthusiasts. With its old-school charm and irresistible square stature, this pizzeria has garnered a devoted following, thanks in part to its rich tomato sauce and sprinkling of Pecorino Romano cheese.

3. Aquila Pizza Al Forno (Little Falls)

For a taste of Neapolitan-ish pizza perfection, look no further than Aquila Pizza Al Forno in Little Falls. Pizzaiolo Jerry Arcieri's meticulous attention to detail shines through in every bite, from the handcrafted mozzarella to the locally sourced tomatoes.

Since 1931, Patsy’s Tavern in Paterson has been a beloved destination for pizza aficionados. Beyond its classic bar pizza with a signature crimped edge, this historic establishment offers a taste of Italian-American tradition.

5. Rosie’s Pizza (Point Pleasant Beach)

Combining contemporary flair with old-school techniques, Rosie’s Pizza in Point Pleasant Beach delivers a pizza experience that strikes the perfect balance between New York-style and Neapolitan. Don’t miss out on their delectable square pies.

6. Star Tavern (City of Orange)

A culinary institution in the City of Orange, Star Tavern is renowned for its iconic pizza featuring a lacy, caramelized crust that extends to the edges. Pro tip: Order it well-done for maximum flavor.

7. Pizza Town, USA (Elmwood Park)

Pizza Town, USA has earned its reputation as a slice of pizza paradise in Elmwood Park. Their legendary cheese pizza, known for its slightly crispy crust and light cheese topping, is a testament to their commitment to perfection.

8. De Lorenzo’s Tomato Pies (Robbinsville Twp)

De Lorenzo’s Tomato Pies in Robbinsville Township offers a unique take on the classic Trenton-style tomato pie. With its thin, crunchy crust and generous toppings of low-moisture mozzarella and crushed plum tomatoes, every bite is a culinary delight.

9. Papa’s Tomato Pies (Robbinsville Twp)

A stone's throw from De Lorenzo’s, Papa’s Tomato Pies delights pizza enthusiasts with its unconventional mustard pie—a flavorful concoction featuring a thin smear of spicy brown mustard atop a perfectly baked crust.

Step into Nancy’s Towne House in Rahway and embark on a culinary journey reminiscent of a bygone era. Their thin-crust pizza, served with a side of Italian-American nostalgia, is a true crowd-pleaser.

Santillo’s Brick Oven Pizza in Elizabeth is a mecca for pizza purists seeking an authentic, old-school experience. Owner Al Santillo's mastery of the craft is evident in every pie, each meticulously crafted to perfection.

DeLucia’s Brick Oven Pizza in Raritan boasts a century-old bread oven that imparts a unique flavor to their pizzas. Featuring a well-done crust and unparalleled pizza sauce, their pies are a testament to tradition and quality.

13. Holy Tomato (Blackwood)

Holy Tomato in Blackwood specializes in Trenton-style pizza, characterized by its thin, crisp crust and generous toppings of flavorful tomato and cheese. Their unique pizza-cutting method adds an extra layer of charm to every slice.

14. Mainline Pizzeria (Little Falls)

Mainline Pizzeria, housed in a retired cable-car diner in Little Falls, is a quintessential New Jersey slice shop. Their cheese pizza, cooked to perfection in a deck oven, offers a nostalgic taste of classic New Jersey pizza.

15. Slice House (Toms River)

Slice House in Toms River may be the new kid on the block, but it's quickly made a name for itself with its diverse selection of pizza styles. Whether you prefer thick squares or thin-crust edge pies, Slice House has something to satisfy every pizza craving.

16. Kinchley’s Tavern (Ramsey)

Kinchley’s Tavern in Ramsey is a beloved destination for thin-crust pizza enthusiasts. With its flavorful sauce and cracker-like crust, their pizzas are a testament to tradition and quality, making every bite a delight.

17. Conte’s Pizza (Princeton)

Princeton's own Conte’s Pizza is renowned for its thin-crust bar pies cooked to crispy perfection. With a cracker-like crust and perfectly charred pepperoni, their pizzas are a must-try for pizza lovers in Mercer County.

18. Maruca’s Tomato Pies (Seaside Heights)

No visit to the Jersey Shore is complete without a stop at Maruca’s Tomato Pies in Seaside Heights. Their whimsically sauced pizza, featuring a unique swirled tomato sauce pattern, is a beloved staple of boardwalk cuisine.

19. Talula’s (Asbury Park)

Talula’s in Asbury Park offers a tantalizing array of brick-oven pizzas and artisanal cocktails. From the signature Beekeeper’s Lament to classic Neapolitan-style pies, every pizza at Talula’s is a culinary masterpiece.

20. Nunzio’s Pizzeria (Long Branch)

Nunzio’s Pizzeria in Long Branch serves up old-school round pies with a generous helping of nostalgia. Their liberally sauced pizzas, baked crisp and flavorful, offer a throwback experience that keeps customers coming back for more.

21. ARTIE’S (Maplewood)

ARTIE’S in Maplewood is a hidden gem known for its delicious Neapolitan-style pizzas. With playful toppings and combinations, their pizzas are a culinary adventure that never fails to impress.

For a taste of Sicilian pizza perfection, look no further than The Original Mr. Bruno’s Pizzeria & Restaurant in Lyndhurst. Their signature upside-down square pies, featuring slices of low-moisture mozzarella and a robust sauce, are a true culinary delight.

23. Prima Pizza Kitchen (Somerville)

Prima Pizza Kitchen in Somerville is a haven for pizza lovers seeking an unforgettable dining experience. Their upside-down round pies, featuring Grande Mozzarella and robust marinara sauce, are a testament to their commitment to quality.

24. Bricco Coal Fired Pizza (Haddon Township)

Bricco Coal Fired Pizza in Haddon Township offers a mouthwatering selection of coal-fired pies. With a perfect balance of chewy crust and flavorful char, their pizzas are a must-try for pizza enthusiasts in Camden County.

25. Razza (Jersey City)

Razza in Jersey City has earned acclaim as one of the best pizza spots in New York. Specializing in quick-fired, Neapolitan-ish pizza, Razza’s Jersey Margherita is a summertime favorite, featuring locally sourced tomatoes and cheese.

Gervasio Italian Family Restaurant in Crosswicks is a cozy pizzeria known for its saucy Trenton tomato pies. Whether you prefer a classic tomato pie or a flavorful grandma pie, Gervasio’s has something to satisfy every pizza craving.

27. BLVD Pizza (Surf City)

BLVD Pizza in Surf City brings a contemporary twist to LBI’s culinary scene with their captivating square pies. Whether you opt for a classic plain or one of their inventive creations, every pizza at BLVD Pizza is a culinary masterpiece.

28. The Galley Pizza & Eatery (Asbury Park)

The Galley Pizza & Eatery in Asbury Park offers a diverse selection of pizzas, from standard style to thin-crust bar pies. With dozens of toppings and combinations to choose from, their pizzas are a feast for the senses.

Angeloni’s Restaurant and Pizzeria in Caldwell is renowned for its thin-crust, to-the-edge pizzas. With cheese and sauce extending to the edge and a perfect crust, their bar pies are a must-try for pizza enthusiasts.

30. Brick + Dough (Montclair)

Brick + Dough in Montclair offers a hip and innovative take on pizza, combining the suppleness of Neapolitan dough with unique toppings. Their gluten-free Detroit pie is a standout, offering a delicious alternative for gluten-sensitive diners.

There you have it, the ultimate guide to the best pizza places in New Jersey! Whether you're a fan of traditional thin-crust bar pies or innovative Detroit-style creations, these 30 pizzerias promise a slice of culinary heaven. Enjoy your pizza adventures across the Garden State!



Copy of Add a heading.png
bottom of page